| SONG TITLE | ORIGINAL SOURCE | CD | VIDEO |
| I Believe in the Sunshine | Live at the Greek Theatre LP | --- | --- |
| I Can't Give Back the Love I Feel for You | Superstar LP | --- | --- |
| I Can't Stop Lovin' You | Live from the Greek Theatre LP | --- | --- | I Cry Alone | Discovery LP | --- | --- |
| I Didn't Get to Sleep At All | The First Time LP | --- | --- |
| I Don't Want a Sometimes Man | B-side to "Puttin' Myself in Your Hands" |
|
--- |
| I Hear a Rhapsody | The Way of Today LP | --- |
|
| I Keep It Hid | Love Story LP |
|
--- |
| I Only Have Eyes for You | Anatomy of Love LP | --- | --- |
| I Still Believe in Christmas |
Firestone Presents Your Christmas Favorites Vol. 7 LP remake version available on: Christmas Album CD |
|
--- |
| I Wanna Be Around | The Ray Anthony Show TV | --- | --- |
| I Was the One Who Loved You | Set Me Free CD | --- | --- |
| I Will Wait for Love | B-side to "Eternity" 7" |
|
--- |
| I Will Wait for You | The Ways of Today LP |
|
--- |
| I Wonder | Color Her Great LP |
|
--- |
| I Would Be Your Friend | Ms. America LP |
|
--- |
| I'd Do It All Again | Superstar LP |
|
--- |
| I'll Be Home | Love Story LP | --- | --- |
| I'll Be Home for Christmas | Christmas Album CD | --- | --- | I'll Have to Say I Love You in a Song | One Hell of a Woman LP | --- | --- |
| I'll Walk the Rest of the Way | A-side 7" |
|
--- |
| I'm Gonna Love You | Superstar LP |
|
--- |
|
I'm Into Something Good (part of a medley) |
Hullabaloo TV Show 1965 | --- | --- |
| I'm So Glad You Found Me | Ultimate Collection CD | --- |
|
| I've Got Your Number | Color Her Great LP | --- | --- | I've Grown Accustomed to His Face | Anatomy of Love LP | --- | --- | I've Never Been a Woman Before | Love Story LP | --- |
|
If Ever You're Lonely | Ultimate Collection CD | --- |
|
If I Had a Hammer | The Hullabaloo TV Show 1965 |
|
--- | If I Were Your Woman | Love Story LP | --- | --- | If I Could Read Your Mind | Love Story LP | --- | --- | If You Love Me Really Love Me | The Ways of Today LP | --- | --- | Il colore dell amore | A-side 7" | --- | --- | In Love for the Very First Time | Discovery II LP | --- |
|
Invitation | Discovery II LP |
|
--- | Is She in Love | Ultimate Collection CD | --- |
|
It Came Upon a Midnight Clear | A-side 7" | --- |
|
It Must Be Him | It Must Be Him LP | --- |
|
It's Not Unusual | Don't Break My Pretty Balloon LP | --- |
|
